Unpopular package
Severity
Medium
Short Description
This package is not very popular.
Suggestion
Unpopular packages may have less maintenance and contain other problems.
Information
Socket's Unpopular Package alert is a Medium severity quality issue. Unpopular packages can introduce a number of security and maintenance concerns:
1. Lack of Community Vetting:
- Popular packages are often widely used and scrutinized by the community. Unpopular packages may not have undergone the same level of review, meaning bugs or vulnerabilities could go unnoticed. With fewer users, issues are less likely to be reported and fixed promptly.
2. Lower Maintenance and Support:
- Unpopular packages are often maintained by a single developer or a very small team. This can lead to slower updates, delayed security patches, and poor documentation. If the package maintainer becomes inactive, you may be stuck with unresolved issues.
3. Higher Risk of Malicious Intent:
- Attackers sometimes target less popular packages to slip malicious code into the ecosystem, hoping they won’t draw much attention. These packages might be part of a typosquatting attack or contain hidden malware that isn't easily detected due to their obscurity.
4. Limited Ecosystem Integration:
- Unpopular packages may have fewer integrations with other tools and libraries, which can lead to compatibility issues down the line. If the package doesn’t follow best practices, it may not work well with other parts of your project.
5. Unpredictable Future:
- Since unpopular packages have a smaller user base, their long-term viability is uncertain. The developer might abandon the project, or it might never gain the necessary traction to become stable and reliable. Depending on such packages can introduce long-term risks to your project.
Recommended actions
Evaluate Package Quality: Investigate the package's code quality, documentation, and community support to ensure it's well-maintained despite its low popularity.
Check for Alternatives: Look for more popular, well-established alternatives that might provide the same functionality with a larger user base and better support.
Test Thoroughly: If you decide to use the package, perform extensive testing to ensure it meets your project's requirements and won't introduce issues.
Monitor Activity: Keep an eye on the package's development activity to ensure it remains actively maintained and secure.
Assess Security: Review the package for potential security vulnerabilities, especially if it's not widely used or well-known.
Examples
Detection Method
This alert is based on download count for npm and PyPI ecosystems. Socket uses a 1k download threshold for unpopular packages.
Additional resources
npm in Review: A 2023 Retrospective on Growth, Security, and Quirky Facts
What to ask yourself before adding an NPM package to your project