A config driven wrapper for amqplib supporting multi-host connections, automatic error recovery, redelivery flood protection, transparent encryption / decryption, channel pooling and publication timeouts
Rascal is a rich pub/sub wrapper around amqplib.
Rascal is a rich pub/sub wrapper for the excellent amqplib. One of the best things about amqplib is that it doesn't make assumptions about how you use it. Another is that it doesn't attempt to abstract away AMQP Concepts. As a result the library offers a great deal of control and flexibility, but the onus is on you adopt appropriate patterns and configuration. You need to be aware that:
Rascal seeks to either solve these problems, make them easier to deal with or bring them to your attention by adding the following to amqplib
Rascal extends the existing RabbitMQ Concepts of Brokers, Vhosts, Exchanges, Queues, Channels and Connections with two new ones
A publication is a named configuration for publishing a message, including the destination queue or exchange, routing configuration, encryption profile and reliability guarantees, message options, etc. A subscription is a named configuration for consuming messages, including the source queue, encryption profile, content encoding, delivery options (e.g. acknowledgement handling and prefetch), etc. These must be configured and supplied when creating the Rascal broker. After the broker has been created the subscriptions and publications can be retrieved from the broker and used to publish and consume messages.
Please refer to the Change Log
RabbitMQ 3.8.0 introduced quorum queues. Although quorum queues may not be suitable in all situations, they provide poison message handling without the need for an external redelivery counter and offer better data safety in the event of a network partition. You can read more about them here and here.
const Broker = require('rascal').BrokerAsPromised;
const config = require('./config');
(async () => {
try {
const broker = await Broker.create(config);
broker.on('error', console.error);
// Publish a message
const publication = await broker.publish('demo_publication', 'Hello World!');
publication.on('error', console.error);
// Consume a message
const subscription = await broker.subscribe('demo_subscription');
subscription
.on('message', (message, content, ackOrNack) => {
console.log(content);
ackOrNack();
})
.on('error', console.error);
} catch (err) {
console.error(err);
}
})();
const Broker = require('rascal').Broker;
const config = require('./config');
Broker.create(config, (err, broker) => {
if (err) throw err;
broker.on('error', console.error);
// Publish a message
broker.publish('demo_publication', 'Hello World!', (err, publication) => {
if (err) throw err;
publication.on('error', console.error);
});
// Consume a message
broker.subscribe('demo_subscription', (err, subscription) => {
if (err) throw err;
subscription
.on('message', (message, content, ackOrNack) => {
console.log(content);
ackOrNack();
})
.on('error', console.error);
});
});
See here for more examples.
There are three situations when Rascal will nack a message without requeue, leading to potential data loss.
The reason Rascal nacks the message is because the alternatives are to leave the message unacknowledged indefinitely, or to rollback and retry the message in an infinite tight loop. This can DDOS your application and cause problems for your infrastructure. Providing you have correctly configured dead letter queues and/or listen to the "invalid_content" and "redeliveries_exceeded" subscriber events, your messages should be safe.
amqplib emits error events when a connection or channel encounters a problem. Rascal will listen for these and provided you use the default configuration will attempt automatic recovery (reconnection etc), however these events can indicate errors in your code, so it's also important to bring them to your attention. Rascal does this by re-emitting the error event, which means if you don't handle them, they will bubble up to the uncaught error handler and crash your application. It is insufficient to register a global uncaughtException handler - doing so without registering individual handlers will prevent your application from crashing, but also prevent Rascal from recovering.
There are four places where you need to register error handlers.
Immediately after obtaining a broker instance
broker.on('error', (err, { vhost, connectionUrl }) => {
console.error('Broker error', err, vhost, connectionUrl);
});
After subscribing to a channel
// Async/Await
try {
const subscription = await broker.subscribe('s1');
subscription
.on('message', (message, content, ackOrNack) => {
// Do stuff with message
})
.on('error', (err) => {
console.error('Subscriber error', err);
});
} catch (err) {
throw new Error(`Rascal config error: ${err.message}`);
}
// Callbacks
broker.subscribe('s1', (err, subscription) => {
if (err) throw new Error(`Rascal config error: ${err.message}`);
subscription
.on('message', (message, content, ackOrNack) => {
// Do stuff with message
})
.on('error', (err) => {
console.error('Subscriber error', err);
});
});
After publishing a message
// Async/Await
try {
const publication = await broker.publish('p1', 'some text');
publication.on('error', (err, messageId) => {
console.error('Publisher error', err, messageId);
});
} catch (err) {
throw new Error(`Rascal config error: ${err.message}`);
}
// Callbacks
broker.publish('p1', 'some text', (err, publication) => {
if (err) throw new Error(`Rascal config error: ${err.message}`);
publication.on('error', (err, messageId) => {
console.error('Publisher error', err, messageId);
});
});
After forwarding a message
// Async/Await
try {
const publication = await broker.forward('p1', message);
publication.on('error', (err, messageId) => {
console.error('Publisher error', err, messageId);
});
} catch (err) {
throw new Error(`Rascal config error: ${err.message}`);
}
// Callbacks
broker.forward('p1', message, (err, publication) => {
if (err) throw new Error(`Rascal config error: ${err.message}`);
publication.on('error', (err, messageId) => {
console.error('Publisher error', err, messageId);
});
});
The broker emits the vhost_initialised event after recovering from a connection error. An object containing the vhost name and connection url (with obfuscated password) are passed to the event handler. e.g.
broker.on('vhost_initialised', ({ vhost, connectionUrl }) => {
console.log(`Vhost: ${vhost} was initialised using connection: ${connectionUrl}`);
});
RabbitMQ notifies clients of blocked and unblocked connections, which rascal forwards from the connection to the broker. e.g.
broker.on('blocked', (reason, { vhost, connectionUrl }) => {
console.log(`Vhost: ${vhost} was blocked using connection: ${connectionUrl}. Reason: ${reason}`);
});
broker.on('unblocked', ({ vhost, connectionUrl }) => {
console.log(`Vhost: ${vhost} was unblocked using connection: ${connectionUrl}.`);
});
Rascal is highly configurable, but ships with what we consider to be sensible defaults (optimised for reliability rather than speed) for production and test environments.
var rascal = require('rascal');
var definitions = require('./your-config.json');
var config = rascal.withDefaultConfig(definitions);
or
var rascal = require('rascal');
var definitions = require('./your-test-config.json');
var config = rascal.withTestConfig(definitions);
We advise you to review these defaults before using them in an environment you care about.
The most common configuration options are
A simple configuration is shown below. You can reference Rascal's JSON schema from the config to enable validation and suggestions in compatible IDEs.
{
"$schema": "./node_modules/rascal/lib/config/schema.json",
"vhosts": {
"/": {
"connection": {
"url": "amqp://user:password@broker.example.com:5742/"
},
"exchanges": ["demo_ex"],
"queues": ["demo_q"],
"bindings": ["demo_ex[a.b.c] -> demo_q"],
"publications": {
"demo_pub": {
"exchange": "demo_ex",
"routingKey": "a.b.c"
}
},
"subscriptions": {
"demo_sub": {
"queue": "demo_q",
"prefetch": 3
}
}
}
}
}
The simplest way to specify a connection is with a url
{
"vhosts": {
"v1": {
"connection": "amqp://guest:guest@broker.example.com:5672/v1?heartbeat=10"
}
}
}
As of Rascal v18.0.0 you must URL encode special characters appearing in the username, password and vhost, e.g. amqp://guest:secr%23t@broker.example.com:5672/v1?heartbeat=10
Alternatively you can specify the individual connection details
{
"vhosts": {
"v1": {
"connection": {
"slashes": true,
"protocol": "amqp",
"hostname": "localhost",
"user": "guest",
"password": "guest",
"port": 5672,
"vhost": "v1",
"options": {
"heartbeat": 5
},
"socketOptions": {
"timeout": 10000
}
}
}
}
}
Special characters do not need to be encoded when specified in this form.
Any attributes you add to the "options" sub document will be converted to query parameters. Any attributes you add in the "socketOptions" sub document will be passed directly to amqplib's connect method (which hands them off to net or tls. Providing you merge your configuration with the default configuration rascal.withDefaultConfig(config) you need only specify the attributes you want to override
{
"vhosts": {
"v1": {
"connection": {
"hostname": "broker.example.com",
"user": "bob",
"password": "secret"
}
}
}
}
Rascal also supports automatic connection retries. It's enabled in the default config, or you want enable it specifically as follows.
{
"vhosts": {
"v1": {
"connection": {
"retry": {
"min": 1000,
"max": 60000,
"factor": 2,
"strategy": "exponential"
}
}
}
}
}
or
{
"vhosts": {
"v1": {
"connection": {
"retry": {
"min": 1000,
"max": 5000,
"strategy": "linear"
}
}
}
}
}
The exponential configuration will cause rascal to retry the connection at exponentially increasing intervals to a maximum of one minute. The intervals are adjusted by a random amount so that if you have multiple services they will not all reconnect at the same time.
The linear configuration will cause rascal to retry the connection at linearly increasing intervals, between one and five seconds.
If you specify an array of connections instead of a single connection object Rascal will order then as per the connection strategy at startup, and cycle through until it obtains a connection or exhausts all hosts.
{
"vhosts": {
"v1": {
"connectionStrategy": "random",
"connections": ["amqp://guest:guest@broker1.example.com:5672/v1?heartbeat=10", "amqp://guest:guest@broker2.example.com:5672/v1?heartbeat=10", "amqp://guest:guest@broker3.example.com:5672/v1?heartbeat=10"]
}
}
}
The default connection strategy is random, but if you prefer an active/passive configuration you should use fixed.
You can see the list of Rascal managed connections by calling broker.getConnections(). This will return an array similar to the following...
[
{ "vhost": "/", "connectionUrl": "amqp://guest:***@localhost:5672?heartbeat=50&connection_timeout=10000&channelMax=100" }
{ "vhost": "other", "connectionUrl": "amqp://guest:***@localhost:5672/other?heartbeat=50&connection_timeout=10000&channelMax=100" }
]
Please note: this functionality is mainly useful in test environments, since it does not create users or grant them permissions to vhosts
The AMQP protocol doesn't support assertion or checking of vhosts, so Rascal uses the RabbitMQ management API to achieve a similar result. The management connection configuration is derived from defaults and the vhost connection, but can be explicitly specified as follows...
{
"vhosts": {
"v1": {
"connection": {
"hostname": "broker.example.com",
"user": "bob",
"password": "secret",
"management": {
"protocol": "https",
"pathname": "prefix",
"user": "admin",
"password": "super-secret",
"options": {
"timeout": 1000
}
}
}
}
}
}
Rascal uses http.request under the hood. URL configuration is also supported.
{
"vhosts": {
"v1": {
"connections": [
{
"url": "amqp://guest:guest@broker1.example.com:5672/v1?heartbeat=10",
"management": "http://guest:guest@broker1.example.com:15672"
},
{
"url": "amqp://guest:guest@broker2.example.com:5672/v1?heartbeat=10",
"management": "http://guest:guest@broker2.example.com:15672"
},
{
"url": "amqp://guest:guest@broker3.example.com:5672/v1?heartbeat=10",
"management": "http://guest:guest@broker3.example.com:15672"
}
]
}
}
}
You can also supply your own agent via the broker components. Use this when you need to set TLS options.
const https = require('https');
const agent = new https.Agent(options);
const components = { agent };
const broker = await Broker.create(config, components);
If you have a high number of exchanges, queues and bindings you may wish to initialise Rascal using multiple channels to improve startup time. Do this per vhost by setting the concurrency attribute to the number of channels you want to create and use.
{
"vhosts": {
"v1": {
"concurrency": 10
}
}
}
When set to true, Rascal will create the vhost if one doesn't exist using the RabbitMQ management API. This requires the management plugin to be installed on the broker and for the management user to have necessary permissions.
{
"vhosts": {
"v1": {
"assert": true
}
}
}
When set to true, Rascal will check that the vhost exists using the RabbitMQ management API. This requires the management plugin to be installed on the broker and for the management user to have necessary permissions.
{
"vhosts": {
"v1": {
"check": true
}
}
}
Rascal useds pools channels it uses for publishing messages. It creates two pools per vhost - one for confirm channels, and other one for regular channels. The default maximum pool size is 5 and the minimum 1, but neither pool will be created until first use (override this by setting autostart: true). Idle channels are automatically evicted from the pool. The pool configuration can be adjusted through config, which is passed through to the underlying generic-pool library.
{
"vhosts": {
"v1": {
"publicationChannelPools": {
"regularPool": {
"max": 10,
"min": 5,
"evictionRunIntervalMillis": 10000,
"idleTimeoutMillis": 60000,
"autostart": true
},
"confirmPool": {
"max": 10,
"min": 5,
"evictionRunIntervalMillis": 10000,
"idleTimeoutMillis": 60000,
"autostart": true
}
}
}
}
}
Unfortunately there is a bug in generic-pool's implementation, which means that if the pool fails to create a channel, it can enter a tight loop, thrashing your CPU and potentially crashing your node process due to a memory leak. While we assess the long term use of pooling, we have put in a workaround. Errors will only be rejected after a configurable delay. This defaults to one second but can be overridden through the rejectionDelayMillis pool attribute. Special thanks to @willthrom for helping diagnose and fix this issue.
amqplib flow control dictates channels act like stream.Writable when Rascal calls channel.publish or channel.sendToQueue, returning false when the channel is saturated and true if it is not. While it is possible to ignore this and keep publishing messages, it is preferable to apply back pressure to the message source. You can do this by listening to the broker busy and ready events. Busy events are emitted when the number of outstanding channel requests reach the pool max size, and ready events emitted when the outstanding channel requests falls back down to zero. The pool details are passed to both event handlers so you can take selective action.
broker.on('busy', ({ vhost, mode, queue, size, available, borrowed, min, max }) => {
if (vhost === 'events') return eventStream.pause();
console.warn(`vhost ${vhost} is busy`);
});
broker.on('ready', ({ vhost, mode, queue, size, available, borrowed, min, max }) => {
if (vhost === 'events') return eventStream.resume();
console.info(`vhost ${vhost} is ready`);
});
Running automated tests against shared queues and exchanges is problematic. Messages left over from a previous test run can cause assertions to fail. Rascal has several strategies which help you cope with this problem, one of which is to namespace your queues and exchange.
{
"vhosts": {
"v1": {
"namespace": true
}
}
}
If you specify "namespace" :true Rascal will prefix the queues and exchanges it creates with a uuid. Alternatively you can specify your own namespace, "namespace": "foo". Namespaces are also if you want to use a single vhost locally but multiple vhosts in other environments.
Setting assert to true will cause Rascal to create the exchange on initialisation. If the exchange already exists and has the same configuration (type, durability, etc) everything will be fine, however if the existing exchange has a different configuration an error will be returned. Assert is enabled in the default configuration.
If you don't want to create exchanges on initialisation, but still want to validate that they exist set assert to false and check to true
{
"vhosts": {
"v1": {
"exchanges": {
"e1": {
"assert": false,
"check": true
}
}
}
}
}
Declares the exchange type. Must be one of direct, topic, headers or fanout. The default configuration sets the exchange type to "topic" unless overridden.
Define any further configuration in an options block
{
"vhosts": {
"v1": {
"exchanges": {
"e1": {
"type": "fanout",
"options": {
"durable": false
}
}
}
}
}
}
Refer to the amqplib documentation for further exchange options.
Setting assert to true will cause Rascal to create the queue on initialisation. If the queue already exists and has the same configuration (durability, etc) everything will be fine, however if the existing queue has a different configuration an error will be returned. Assert is enabled in the default configuration.
If you don't want to create queues on initialisation, but still want to validate that they exist set assert to false and check to true
{
"vhosts": {
"v1": {
"queues": {
"q1": {
"assert": false,
"check": true
}
}
}
}
}
Enable to purge the queue during initialisation. Useful when running automated tests
{
"vhosts": {
"v1": {
"queues": {
"q1": {
"purge": true
}
}
}
}
}
Sometimes you want to publish a message, and have the consumer of the message send a reply to the same application instance that published the original message. This can be difficult if you application is deployed using multiple instances which share a common configuration. Quite often the solution is to make your application stateless so it doesn't matter which instance receives the reply. An alternative is to mark the queue as a reply queue using the replyTo.
{
"queues": {
"q1": {
"replyTo": true
}
},
"publications": {
"exchange": "e1",
"replyTo": "q1"
}
}
When true, Rascal will append a uuid to the queue name so that it is unique for each instance of the application. Use this conjunction with the publication replyTo property, to automatically set the replyTo property on outbound messages to the unique queue name. You may also want to make the queue non durable and exclusive too (see below).
Define any further configuration in an options block
{
"queues": {
"q1": {
"options": {
"durable": false,
"exclusive": true
}
}
}
}
To define a queue with extensions such as x-queue-type add arguments to the options block, e.g.
{
"queues": {
"q1": {
"options": {
"durable": false,
"arguments": {
"x-message-ttl": 65000,
"x-queue-mode": "lazy"
}
}
}
}
}
Refer to the amqplib documentation for further queue options.
Rascal supports RabbitMQ Streams via x-queue-type argument, i.e.
{
"queues": {
"q1": {
"options": {
"arguments": {
"x-queue-type": "stream"
}
}
}
}
}
The Stream Plugin and associated binary protocol extension are not supported.
Streams are not a replacement for regular messaging - instead they are best suited for when you can tolerate occasional message loss and need for higher throughput, such as sampling web based analytics.
When working with streams you need to think carefully about data retention. Unless you specify retention configuration, messages will never be deleted and eventually you will run out of space. Conversely, if you automatically delete messages based on queue size or age, they may be lost without ever being read.
You also need to think about how you will track the consumer offset. Typically you will need to store this in a database after successfully processing the message and use it to tell the broker where to resume from after your application restarts. For example...
const initialOffset = (await loadOffset('/my-queue')) || 'first';
const overrides = {
options: {
arguments: {
'x-stream-offset': initialOffset
}
}
};
const subscription = await broker.subscribe('/my-queue', overrides);
subscription.on('message', async (message, content, ackOrNack) => {
const currentOffset = message.properties.headers['x-stream-offset'];
try {
await handleMessage(content);
await updateOffset('/my-queue', currentOffset);
} catch (err) {
await handleError('/my-queue', currentOffset, err);
} finally {
ackOrNack(); // Streams do not support nack so do not pass the error argument
}
});
However, if your application is offline for too long, and messages are still being published to the stream, it may not be able to resume from where you left off, since those messages may have been deleted. Furthermore, if your application consumes messages concurrently, you need to think about how you will recover should one fail. If you naively override the previouly saved offset, you may be replacing a higher/later offset with an lower/older one, causing in your application to restart from the wrong point. Finally, you also need to decide what to do if the message cannot be processed. You cannot simply replay the message since you are working with a stream, rather than a queue. You could cancel the subscription and resume from the current offset, but this will lead to duplicates if you have been consuming messages concurrently. Alternatively you could republish the failures to a dead letter queue and process them separately.
For the above reasons, we only recommend considering streams when you genuinely need the extra throughput.
You can bind exchanges to exchanges, or exchanges to queues.
{
"vhosts": {
"v1": {
"exchanges": {
"e1": {}
},
"queues": {
"q1": {}
},
"bindings": {
"b1": {
"source": "e1",
"destination": "q1",
"destinationType": "queue",
"bindingKey": "foo"
}
}
}
}
}
When using Rascals defaults, destinationType will default to "queue" and "bindingKey" will default to "#" (although this is only applicable for topics anyway)
Should you want to bind a destination to the same source with multiple binding keys, instead of duplicating the configuration you can specify an array of binding keys using either the "bindingKey" or "bindingKeys" attribute
{
"vhosts": {
"v1": {
"exchanges": {
"e1": {}
},
"queues": {
"q1": {}
},
"bindings": {
"b1": {
"source": "e1",
"destination": "q1",
"destinationType": "queue",
"bindingKeys": ["foo", "bar"]
}
}
}
}
}
If you want to bind to a headers exchange specify the appropriate binding options
{
"vhosts": {
"v1": {
"exchanges": {
"e1": {
"type": "headers"
}
},
"queues": {
"q1": {}
},
"bindings": {
"b1": {
"source": "e1",
"destination": "q1",
"options": {
"x-match": "all",
"foo": "bar"
}
}
}
}
}
}
Now that you've bound your queues and exchanges, you need to start sending them messages. This is where publications come in.
{
"publications": {
"p1": {
"vhost": "v1",
"exchange": "e1",
"routingKey": "foo"
}
}
}
broker.publish('p1', 'some message');
If you prefer to send messages to a queue
{
"publications": {
"p1": {
"vhost": "v1",
"queue": "q1"
}
}
}
To save you entering the vhost you can nest publications inside the vhost block. Rascal also creates default publications for every queue and exchange so providing you don't need to specify any additional options you don't need to include a publications block at all. Auto created publications have the following configuration
{
"publications": {
"/e1": {
"vhost": "/",
"exchange": "e1",
"autoCreated": true
},
"v1/q1": {
"vhost": "/",
"queue": "q1",
"autoCreated": true
}
}
}
Rascal supports text, buffers and anything it can JSON.stringify. Rascal will automatically set the content type to text/plain for strings, application/json for objects and application/octet-stream when encrypting messages. Alternatively you can explicitly set the content type through the contentType option.
The broker.publish method is overloaded to accept a runtime routing key or options.
broker.publish('p1', 'some message', callback);
broker.publish('p1', 'some message', 'some.routing.key', callback);
broker.publish('p1', 'some message', {
routingKey: 'some.routing.key',
options: { messageId: 'foo', expiration: 5000 },
});
await broker.publish('p1', 'some message');
await broker.publish('p1', 'some message', 'some.routing.key');
await broker.publish('p1', 'some message', {
routingKey: 'some.routing.key',
options: { messageId: 'foo', expiration: 5000 },
});
The callback parameters are err (indicating the publication could not be found) and publication. Listen to the publication's "success" event to obtain confirmation that the message was successfully published (when using confirm channels) and the "error" event to handle errors. The "return" event will be emitted when the message was successfully published but not routed. It is possible to access the messageId from all handlers, either via the supplied messageId or the returned message itself (see below)
If you specify the "mandatory" option (or use Rascal's defaults) you can also listen for returned messages (i.e. messages that were not delivered to any queues). Before a message is returned, you will still get the "success" event, since the message was successfully published. A common mistake is to resolve a promise from the "success" event handler and reject from the "return" event handler, since the latter would have no effect.
broker.publish('p1', 'some message', (err, publication) => {
if (err) throw err; // publication didn't exist
publication
.on('success', (messageId) => {
console.log('Message id was: ', messageId);
})
.on('error', (err, messageId) => {
console.error('Error was: ', err.message);
})
.on('return', (message) => {
console.warn('Message was returned: ', message.properties.messageId);
});
});
try {
const publication = await broker.publish('p1', 'some message');
publication
.on('success', (messageId) => {
console.log('Message id was: ', messageId);
})
.on('error', (err, messageId) => {
console.error('Error was: ', err.message);
})
.on('return', (message) => {
console.warn('Message was returned: ', message.properties.messageId);
});
} catch (err) {
// publication didn't exist
}
One publish option you should be aware of is the "persistent". Unless persistent is true, your messages will be discarded when you restart Rabbit. Despite having an impact on performance Rascal sets this in its default configuration.
Refer to the amqplib documentation for further exchange options.
It's important to realise that even though publication emits a "success" event, this offers no guarantee that the message has been sent UNLESS you use a confirm channel. Providing you use Rascal's defaults publications will always be confirmed.
{
"publications": {
"p1": {
"exchange": "e1",
"vhost": "v1",
"confirm": true
}
}
}
If you would like to publish directly to a queue, but you don't know the queue name ahead of time, you can use the fact that all queues are automatically bound to the default exchange with the routing key which is the same as the queue name.
You can publish directly to the queue:
broker.publish('/', 'content', 'q1', (err, publication) => { ... });
See the "default-exchange" in the examples directory for a full working example.
When you publish a message using a confirm channel, amqplib will wait for an acknowledgement that the message was safely received by the broker, and in a clustered environment replicated to all nodes. If something goes wrong, the broker will not send the acknowledgement, amqplib will never execute the callback, and the associated flow of execution will never be resumed. Rascal guards against this by adding publication timeouts. If the timeout expires, then Rascal will close the channel and emit a error event from the publication, however there will still be an unavoidable memory leak as amqplib's callback will never be cleared up. The default timeout is 10 seconds but can be overridden in config. The setting is ignored for normal channels and can be disabled by specifying 0.
{
"publications": {
"p1": {
"exchange": "e1",
"vhost": "v1",
"confirm": true,
"timeout": 10000
}
}
}
If you start experiencing publication timeouts you may find it useful to monitor the publication statistics via the publication.stats object, which includes the duration of Rascal's low level publish operations.
Rascal uses a channel pool to publish messages. Access to the channel pool is synchronised via an in memory queue, which will be paused if the connection to the broker is temporarily lost. Consequently instead of erroring, publishes will be held until the connection is re-established. If you would rather abort under these circumstances, you can listen for the publication 'paused' event, and call publication.abort(). When the connection is re-established any aborted messages will be dropped instead of published.
broker.publish('p1', 'some message', (err, publication) => {
if (err) throw err; // publication didn't exist
publication
.on('success', (messageId) => {
console.log('Message id was: ', messageId);
})
.on('error', (err, messageId) => {
console.error('Error was: ', err.message);
})
.on('paused', (messageId) => {
console.warn('Publication was paused. Aborting message: ', messageId);
publication.abort();
});
});
try {
const publication = await broker.publish('p1', 'some message');
publication
.on('success', (messageId) => {
console.log('Message id was: ', messageId);
})
.on('error', (err, messageId) => {
console.error('Error was: ', err.message);
})
.on('paused', (messageId) => {
console.warn('Publication was paused. Aborting message: ', messageId);
publication.abort();
});
} catch (err) {
// publication didn't exist
}
Rascal can be configured to automatically encrypt outbound messages.
{
"vhosts": {
"v1": {
"exchanges": ["e1"]
}
},
"publications": {
"p1": {
"exchange": "e1",
"vhost": "v1",
"confirm": true,
"encryption": "well-known-v1"
}
},
"encryption": {
"well-known-v1": {
"key": "f81db52a3b2c717fe65d9a3b7dd04d2a08793e1a28e3083db3ea08db56e7c315",
"ivLength": 16,
"algorithm": "aes-256-cbc"
}
}
}
Rascal will set the content type for encrypted messages to 'application/octet-stream'. It stashes the original content type in a header. Providing you use a correctly configured subscription, the message will be automatically decrypted, and normal content handling applied.
Sometimes you want to forward a message to a publication. This may be part of a shovel program for transferring messages between vhosts, or because you want to ensure a sequence in some workflow, but do not need to modify the original message. Rascal supports this via broker.forward. The syntax is similar to broker.publish except from you pass in the original message you want to be forwarded instead of the message payload. If the publication or overrides don't specify a routing key, the original forwarding key will be maintained. The message will also be CC'd with an additional routingkey of <queue>.<routingKey> which can be useful for some retry scenarios.
broker.forward('p1', message, overrides, (err, publication) => {
if (err) throw err; // publication didn't exist
publication
.on('success', (messageId) => {
console.log('Message id was: ', messageId);
})
.on('error', (err, messageId) => {
console.error('Error was: ', err.message);
})
.on('return', (message) => {
console.warn('Message was returned: ', message.properties.messageId);
});
});
try {
const publication = await broker.forward('p1', message, overrides);
publication
.on('success', (messageId) => {
console.log('Message id was: ', messageId);
})
.on('error', (err, messageId) => {
console.error('Error was: ', err.message);
})
.on('return', (message) => {
console.warn('Message was returned: ', message.properties.messageId);
});
} catch (err) {
// publication didn't exist
}
Prior to version 10.0.0, if you used Rascal to consume a forwarded message, the subscriber would automatically restore the original routing key and exchange to the message.fields before emitting it. This was added to support the delayed retry loop advanced recovery strategy, but should not have been applied to broker.forward. From version 10.0.0 this behaviour has been disabled for broker.forward but you can turn it back on by setting restoreRoutingHeaders to true in the overrides. You can also disable this behaviour in the forward and republish recovery strategies by setting restoreRoutingHeaders to false.
Since there is no native, transactional support for forwarding in amqplib, you are at risk of receiving duplicate messages when using broker.forward
The real fun begins with subscriptions
{
"subscriptions": {
"s1": {
"queue": "e1",
"vhost": "v1"
}
}
}
broker.subscribe('s1', (err, subscription) => {
if (err) throw err; // subscription didn't exist
subscription
.on('message', (message, content, ackOrNack) => {
// Do stuff with message
})
.on('error', (err) => {
console.error('Subscriber error', err);
});
});
try {
const subscription = await broker.subscribe('s1');
subscription
.on('message', (message, content, ackOrNack) => {
// Do stuff with message
})
.on('error', (err) => {
console.error('Subscriber error', err);
});
} catch (err) {
// subscription didn't exist
}
It's very important that you handle errors emitted by the subscriber. If not an underlying channel error will bubble up to the uncaught error handler and crash your node process.
Prior to Rascal 4.0.0 it was also very important not to go async between getting the subscription and listening for the message or error events. If you did, you risked leaking messages and not handling errors. For Rascal 4.0.0 and beyond, subscriptions are lazily applied when you add the message handler. Because registering event handlers is synchronous, but setting up RabbitMQ consumers is asynchronous, we've also added the subscribed event in case you need to wait until the subscription has been successfully established.
Rascal supports text, buffers and anything it can JSON.parse, providing the contentType message property is set correctly. Text messages should be set to "text/plain" and JSON messages to "application/json". Other content types will be returned as a Buffer. If the publisher doesn't set the contentType or you want to override it you can do so in the subscriber configuration.
{
"subscriptions": {
"s1": {
"queue": "e1",
"vhost": "v1",
"contentType": "application/json"
}
}
}
The broker.subscribe method also accepts an options parameter which will override options specified in config
broker.subscribe('s1', { prefetch: 10, retry: false }, callback);
await subscription = broker.subscribe("s1", { prefetch: 10, retry: false })
The arguments passed to the message event handler are function(message, content, ackOrNack), where message is the raw message, the content (a buffer, text, or object) and an ackOrNack callback. This ackOrNack callback should only be used for messages which were not { "options": { "noAck": true } } by the subscription configuration or the options passed to broker.subscribe. For more details on acking or nacking messages see Message Acknowledgement and Recovery Strategies.
As with publications, you can nest subscriptions inside the vhost block. Rascal creates default subscriptions for every queue so providing you don't need to specify any additional options you don't need to include a subscriptions block at all.
You can subscribe to multiple subscriptions using broker.subscribeAll.
broker.subscribeAll((err, subscriptions) => {
if (err) throw err; // one or more subscriptions didn't exist
subscriptions.forEach((subscription) => {
subscription
.on('message', (message, content, ackOrNack) => {
// Do stuff with message
})
.on('error', (err) => {
console.error('Subscriber error', err);
});
});
});
try {
const subscriptions = await broker.subscribeAll();
subscriptions.forEach((subscription) => {
subscription
.on('message', (message, content, ackOrNack) => {
// Do stuff with message
})
.on('error', (err) => {
console.error('Subscriber error', err);
});
});
} catch (err) {
// One or more subscriptions didn't exist
}
subscribeAll takes a filter so you can ignore subscriptions if required. This is especially useful for ignoring the rascals default subscriptions. e.g.
broker.subscribeAll(
(s) => !s.autoCreated,
(err, subscriptions) => {
if (err) throw err; // one or more subscriptions didn't exist
subscriptions.forEach((subscription) => {
subscription
.on('message', (message, content, ackOrNack) => {
// Do stuff with message
})
.on('error', (err) => {
console.error('Subscriber error', err);
});
});
}
);
try {
const subscriptions = await broker.subscribeAll(s => !s.autoCreated) => {
subscriptions.forEach(subscription => {
subscription.on('message', (message, content, ackOrNack) => {
// Do stuff with message
}).on('error', (err) => {
console.error('Subscriber error', err)
})
});
} catch(err) {
// One or more subscriptions didn't exist
}
If rascal can't parse the content (e.g. the message had a content type of 'application/json' but the content was not JSON), it will emit an 'invalid_content' event
broker.subscribe('s1', (err, subscription) => {
if (err) throw err; // subscription didn't exist
subscription
.on('message', (message, content, ackOrNack) => {
// Do stuff with message
})
.on('error', (err) => {
console.error('Subscriber error', err);
})
.on('invalid_content', (err, message, ackOrNack) => {
console.error('Invalid content', err);
ackOrNack(err);
});
});
try {
const subscription = await broker.subscribe('s1');
subscription
.on('message', (message, content, ackOrNack) => {
// Do stuff with message
})
.on('error', (err) => {
console.error('Subscriber error', err);
})
.on('invalid_content', (err, message, ackOrNack) => {
console.error('Invalid content', err);
ackOrNack(err);
});
} catch (err) {
// subscription didn't exist
}
If the message has not been auto-acknowledged you should ackOrNack it. If you do not listen for the invalid_content event rascal will nack the message (without requeue) and emit an error event instead, leading to message loss if you have not configured a dead letter exchange/queue.
The RabbitMQ broker may cancel the consumer if the queue is deleted or the node on which the queue is located fails. amqplib handles this by delivering a null message. When Rascal receives the null message it will
cancel event from the subscription.error event from the subscription if the cancel event was not handledRascal can be configured to automatically decrypt inbound messages.
{
"vhosts": {
"v1": {
"queues": ["e1"]
}
},
"subscriptions": {
"s1": {
"queue": "e1",
"vhost": "v1"
}
},
"encryption": {
"well-known-v1": {
"key": "f81db52a3b2c717fe65d9a3b7dd04d2a08793e1a28e3083db3ea08db56e7c315",
"ivLength": 16,
"algorithm": "aes-256-cbc"
}
}
}
Any message that was published using the "well-known-v1" encryption profile will be automatically decrypted by the subscriber.
If your app crashes before acknowledging a message, the message will be rolled back. It is common for node applications to automatically restart, however if the crash was caused by something in the message content, it will crash and restart indefinitely, thrashing the host. Prior to version 3.8.0, RabbitMQ didn't allow you to limit the number of redeliveries per message or provide a redelivery count. This is now possible using quorum queues, but for those on older versions, or in situations where quorum queues are not appropriate, subscribers can be configured with a redelivery counter and will update the message.properties.headers.rascal.redeliveries header with the number of hits. If the number of redeliveries exceeds the subscribers limit, the subscriber will emit a "redeliveries_exceeded" event, and can be handled by your application. e.g.
"subscriptions": {
"s1": {
"vhost": "/",
"queue": "q1",
"redeliveries": {
"limit": 10,
"counter": "<counter name>"
}
}
},
"redeliveries": {
"counters": {
"<counter name>": {
"type": "<counter type>",
"size": 1000,
}
}
}
broker.subscribe('s1', (err, subscription) => {
if (err) throw err; // subscription didn't exist
subscription
.on('message', (message, content, ackOrNack) => {
// Do stuff with message
})
.on('error', (err) => {
console.error('Subscriber error', err);
})
.on('redeliveries_exceeded', (err, message, ackOrNack) => {
console.error('Redeliveries exceeded', err);
ackOrNack(err);
});
});
try {
const subscription = await broker.subscribe('s1');
subscription
.on('message', (message, content, ackOrNack) => {
// Do stuff with message
})
.on('error', (err) => {
console.error('Subscriber error', err);
})
.on('redeliveries_exceeded', (err, message, ackOrNack) => {
console.error('Redeliveries exceeded', err);
ackOrNack(err);
});
} catch (err) {
// subscription didn't exist
}
If you do not listen for the redeliveries_exceeded event rascal will nack the message without requeue leading to message loss if you have not configured a dead letter exchange/queue.
Rascal provides three counter implementations:
Of the three only inMemoryCluster is useful in production, and then only if you are using clustering. See the advanced example for how to configure it.
If your application is not clustered, but you still want to protect yourself from redeliveries, you need to implement your own counter backed by something like redis. In times of high message volumes the counter will be hit hard so you should make sure it's fast and resilient to failure/slow responses from the underlying store.
See here for a redis backed counter.
For messages which are not auto-acknowledged (the default) calling ackOrNack() with no arguments will acknowledge it. Calling ackOrNack(err) will nack the message using Rascal's default recovery strategy (nack with requeue). Calling ackOrNack(err, recoveryOptions) will trigger the specified recovery strategy or strategies. You can also acknowledge all outstanding messages on the channel by calling ackOrNack(null, { all: true }).
When using the callback API, you can call ackOrNack without a callback and errors will be emitted by the subscription. Alternatively you can specify a callback as the final argument irrespective of what other arguments you provide.
When using the promises API, ackOrNack will work as for the callback API unless you explicitly set promisifyAckOrNack to true on the subscription. If you do enable this feature, be sure to catch rejections.
ackOrNack(err, { strategy: 'nack' });
Nack causes the message to be discarded or routed to a dead letter exchange if configured. You can also negatively acknowledge all outstanding messages on a channel as follows
ackOrNack(err, { strategy: 'nack', all: true });
ackOrNack(err, { strategy: 'nack', defer: 1000, requeue: true });
The defer option is not mandatory, but without it you are likely retry your message thousands of times a second. Even then requeuing is an inadequate strategy for error handling, since the message will be rolled back to the front of the queue and there is no simple way to detect how many times the message has been redelivered.
Dead lettering is a good option for invalid messages but with one major flaw - because the message cannot be modified it cannot be annotated with the error details. This makes it difficult to do anything useful with messages once dead lettered.
ackOrNack(err, { strategy: 'republish', defer: 1000 });
An alternative to nacking to republish the message back to the queue it came from. This has the advantage that the message will be resent to the back of the queue, allowing other messages to be processed and potentially fixing errors relating to ordering.
Rascal keeps track of the number of republishes so you can limit the number of attempts. Whenever you specify a number of attempts you should always chain a fallback strategy, otherwise if the attempts are exceeded your message will be neither acked or nacked.
ackOrNack(err, [{ strategy: 'republish', defer: 1000, attempts: 10 }, { strategy: 'nack' }]);
Rascal also annotates the message with detail of the error message.properties.headers.rascal.<queue>.error which can be useful if you eventually dead letter it.
Before using republish please consider the following:
Rascal will copy messages properties from the original message to the republished one. If you set an expiration time on the original message this will also be recopied, effectively resetting it.
Rascal will ack the original message after successfully publishing the copy. This does not take place in a distributed transaction so there is a potential of the original message being rolled back after the copy has been published (the dead-letter delay loop also suffers from this).
Rascal will republish original message using a confirm channel, if the publish fails, the original message will not be nacked (You should mitigate this by chaining recovery strategies).
Republishing has the side-effect of clearing message.fields.exchange and setting message.fields.routingKey to the queue name. These fields may be used by your application or by the broker when routing rejected messages to a dead letter exchange. Rascal mitigates the first of these problems by restoring the original values before passing the message to the consumer, however if the message is subsequently rejected/nacked, this information will no longer be available on the broker's copy of the message and may still cause problems for dead letter routing. To resolve this you can bind the dead letter queue to the dead letter exchange twice, using both the original routing key pattern and the queue name. Alternatively you can specify an explicit dead letter routing key by way of the x-dead-letter-routing-key argument when defining the queue.
As mentioned previously, dead lettering invalid messages is a good strategy with one flaw - since there is no way to modify the message you cannot annotate it with failure details. A solution to this is to republish with attempts = 1 and then nacking it to a dead letter exchange. The problem with this approach is that invalid messages will always be processed twice. To workaround this set immediateNack to true in the recovery options. This will instruct Rascal to nack the message immediately instead of emitting the 'message' event.
ackOrNack(err, { strategy: 'republish', immediateNack: true });
Prior to Rascal v20.1.0, if you wanted to resend the message to the original queue you had to remove the properties.headers.rascal.<queue>.immediateNack header first. From v20.1.0, Rascal will ignore and remove the immediateNack header if the message's xDeath header indicates that the message was dead lettered after it was republished with immediateNack.
Instead of republishing the message to the same queue you can forward it to a Rascal publication. You should read the section entitled Forwarding messages to understand the risks of this.
ackOrNack(err, { strategy: 'forward', publication: 'some_exchange' });
Danger As with the Republish strategy, you can limit the number of forward attempts. Whenever you specify a number of attempts you should always chain a fallback strategy, otherwise if the attempts are exceeded your message will be neither acked or nacked.
Furthermore if the message is forwarded but cannot be routed (e.g. due to an incorrect binding), the message will be returned after Rascal receives a 'success' event from amqplib. Consequently the message will have been ack'd. Any subsequent fallback strategy which attempts to ack or nack the message will fail, and so the message may lost. The subscription will emit an error event under such circumstances.
ackOrNack(err, [
{
strategy: 'forward',
publication: 'some_exchange',
defer: 1000,
attempts: 10,
},
{ strategy: 'nack' },
]);
You can also override the publication options
ackOrNack(err, [
{
strategy: 'forward',
publication: 'some_exchange',
options: { routingKey: 'custom.routing.key' },
},
{ strategy: 'nack' },
]);
One use of the forward recovery strategy is to send messages to a wait queue which will dead-letter them after a period of time. Repeated dead lettering causes some versions of RabbitMQ to crash. If you encounter this issue upgrade RabbitMQ or specify xDeathFix: true which will delete any x-death headers on the message before forwarding.
Acknowledges the message, guaranteeing that it will be discarded in the event you also have a dead letter exchange configured. Sometimes useful in automated tests or when chaining a sequence of other recovery strategies.
ackOrNack(err, { strategy: 'ack' });
By chaining Rascal's recovery strategies and leveraging some of RabbitMQ's lesser used features such as message you can achieve some quite sophisticated error handling. A simple combination of republish and nack (with dead letter) will enable you to retry the message a maximum number of times before dead letting it.
ackOrNack(err, [
{
strategy: 'republish',
defer: 1000,
attempts: 10,
},
{
strategy: 'nack',
},
]);
Far more sophisticated strategies are achievable...
Steps 3 - 7 will repeat up to attempts times. If all attempts fail...
Prefetch limits the number of unacknowledged messages a subscription can have outstanding. It's a great way to ensure that you don't overload your event loop or a downstream service. Rascal's default configuration sets the prefetch to 10 which may seem low, but we've managed to knock out firewalls, breach AWS thresholds and all sorts of other things by setting it to higher values.
Channel prefetch is like prefetch but operates at a channel rather than a consumer level. Since Rascal uses a dedicated channel per subscriber there is rarely any point setting it. Moreover, a channel prefetch has a considerable overhead, especially in a clustered environment so can significantly impact performance. The only reason to set a channel prefetch is if you want to adjust the prefetch dynamically after the subscription has started, and without cancelling the subscription, e.g.
broker.subscribe('s1', { prefetch: 0, channelPrefetch: 5 }, (err, subscription) => {
if (err) throw err;
subscription.on('message', (message, content, ackOrNack) => {
ackOrNack();
const prefetch = tunePrefetch();
subscription.setChannelPrefetch(prefetch, (err) => {
if (err) throw err;
});
});
});
const subscription = await broker.subscribe('s1', { prefetch: 0, channelPrefetch: 5 });
subscription.on('message', (message, content, ackOrNack) => {
ackOrNack();
const prefetch = tunePrefetch();
await subscription.setChannelPrefetch(prefetch);
});
Don't forget to zero the regular consumer prefetch when specifying a channelPrefetch to prevent potential conflicts.
If an error occurs on the channel (which will happen if you accidentally acknowledge a message twice), then it becomes unusable and no more messages will be delivered. Rascal listens to the channel's error even and assuming you are using its defaults will automatically attempt to resubscribe to a new channel after a one second delay. You can disable or customise this in your configuration or in the call to subscribe.
// Does not retry. This will cause an error to be emitted which unhandled will crash your process. See [Subscriber Events](#subscriber-events)
broker.subscribe('s1', { prefetch: 10, retry: false }, callback);
// Retries without delay.
broker.subscribe('s1', { prefetch: 10, retry: true }, callback);
// Retries after a one second interval.
broker.subscribe('s1', { prefetch: 10, retry: { delay: 1000 } }, callback);
// Does not retry. This will cause an error to be emitted which unhandled will crash your process. See [Subscriber Events](#subscriber-events)
await broker.subscribe('s1', { prefetch: 10, retry: false });
// Retries without delay.
await broker.subscribe('s1', { prefetch: 10, retry: true });
// Retries after a one second interval.
await broker.subscribe('s1', { prefetch: 10, retry: { delay: 1000 } });
amqplib emits error events from the channel. These can happen for a number of reasons, but a common cause is because you have acknowledged the message twice. The subscriber will listen for channel errors so it can automatically re-subscribe but still emits them so they can be reported by your application. If you don not listen to these events or handle them in a domain they will cause your application to crash.
Configuring each vhost, exchange, queue, binding, publication and subscription explicitly wouldn't be much fun. Not only does Rascal ship with default production and test configuration files, but you can also specify your own defaults in your configuration files by adding a "defaults" sub document.
{
"defaults": {
"vhosts": {
"exchanges": {
"assert": true,
"type": "topic"
},
"queues": {
"assert": true
},
"bindings": {
"destinationType": "queue",
"bindingKey": "#"
}
},
"publications": {
"vhost": "/",
"confirm": true,
"options": {
"persistent": true
}
},
"subscriptions": {
"vhost": "/",
"prefetch": 10,
"retry": {
"delay": 1000
},
"redeliveries": {
"counter": {
"size": 1000
},
"limit": 1000
}
}
}
}
You can cancel subscriptions as follows
broker.subscribe('s1', (err, subscription) => {
if (err) throw err; // subscription didn't exist
subscription.cancel((err) => {
console.error(err);
});
});
try {
const subscription = await broker.subscribe('s1');
await subscription.cancel();
} catch (err) {
// subscription didn't exist or could not be cancelled
}
Cancelling a subscription will stop consuming messages, but leave the channel open until any outstanding messages have been acknowledged, or the timeout specified by through the closeTimeout subscription property is exceeded.
You can shutdown the broker by calling await broker.shutdown() or broker.shutdown(cb).
Rascal configuration can get rather verbose, so you can use the shorthand notation
{
"exchanges": {
"e1": {},
"e2": {}
},
"queues": {
"q1": {},
"q2": {}
},
"bindings": {
"b1": {
"source": "e1",
"destination": "q1"
},
"b2": {
"source": "e2",
"destination": "q2",
"bindingKeys": ["bk1", "bk2"]
}
}
}
is equivalent to...
{
"exchanges": ["e1", "e2"],
"queues": ["q1", "q2"],
"bindings": ["e1 -> q1", "e2[bk1, bk2] -> q2"]
}
If you need to specify exchange, queue or binding parameters you can mix and match string and object configuration...
{
"exchanges": {
"e1": {},
"e2": {
"type": "fanout"
}
}
}
is equivalent to...
{
"exchanges": [
"e1",
{
"name": "e2",
"type": "fanout"
}
]
}
Rascal is a rich pub/sub wrapper and as such hides much of the amqplib channel api. If you need to access this you can programmatically establish a connection to a vhost as follows.
broker.connect('/', (err, connection) => {
if (err) throw new Error(`Connection error: ${err.message}`);
// profit
});
try {
const connection = broker.connect('/');
// profit
} catch (err) {
throw new Error(`Connection error: ${err.message}`);
}
This will leverage Rascal's cluster connection support, but you will be responsible for error handling and disconnection.
In a test environment it's useful to be able to nuke your setup between tests. The specifics will vary based on your test runner, but assuming you were using Mocha...
afterEach((done) => {
broker.nuke(done);
});
afterEach(async () => {
await broker.nuke();
});
It can be costly to nuke between tests, so if you want the tear down to be quicker use the purge and unsubscribeAll.
afterEach((done) => {
async.series([broker.unsubscribeAll, broker.purge], done);
});
after((done) => {
broker.nuke(done);
});
afterEach(async () => {
await broker.unsubscribeAll();
await broker.purge();
});
after(async () => {
await broker.nuke();
});
Bounce disconnects and reinitialises the broker.
beforeEach((done) => {
broker.bounce(done);
});
beforeEach(async () => {
await broker.bounce();
});
RabbitMQ enables you to transfer messages between brokers using the Shovel plugin. You can do something similar with rascal by connecting a subscription to a publication. Shovel relies on rascals 'forward' feature, so all the caveats about duplicate messages apply.
{
"shovels": {
"x1": {
"subscription": "s1",
"publication": "p1"
}
}
}
or in shorthand
{
"shovels": ["s1 -> p1"]
}
npm test
You'll need a RabbitMQ server running locally with default configuration. If that's too much trouble try installing docker and running the following
npm run docker
20.1.0
FAQs
A config driven wrapper for amqplib supporting multi-host connections, automatic error recovery, redelivery flood protection, transparent encryption / decryption, channel pooling and publication timeouts
The npm package rascal receives a total of 8,530 weekly downloads. As such, rascal popularity was classified as popular.
We found that rascal demonstrated a healthy version release cadence and project activity because the last version was released less than a year ago. It has 4 open source maintainers collaborating on the project.
Did you know?
Socket for GitHub automatically highlights issues in each pull request and monitors the health of all your open source dependencies. Discover the contents of your packages and block harmful activity before you install or update your dependencies.
Security News
In this segment of the Risky Business podcast, Feross Aboukhadijeh and Patrick Gray discuss the challenges of tracking malware discovered in open source softare.
Research
Security News
A threat actor's playbook for exploiting the npm ecosystem was exposed on the dark web, detailing how to build a blockchain-powered botnet.
Security News
NVD’s backlog surpasses 20,000 CVEs as analysis slows and NIST announces new system updates to address ongoing delays.