dsh-win-multi-bash

English | 中文

dsh-win-multi-bash

A Windows multi-bash plugin for DeepSeek Harness: the git_bash / wsl_bash model tools, each owning its own Git Bash / WSL executor. The plugin never touches the ctx.shell seat — dsh's own pwsh executor keeps it — so pwsh behavior is identical to a deployment without the plugin.

What it provides

Tool	Backend	Dialect	Notes
git_bash	git-bash	MSYS	Owns a GitBashExecutor; Git for Windows toolchain
wsl_bash	wsl-bash	Linux	Owns a WslBashExecutor; WSL distro Linux userland
pwsh (dsh's own)	pwsh	—	Served by the base bundle's pwsh-sandbox row, untouched by this plugin

• Each tool constructs and drives its own executor; neither registers as ctx.shell, so the seat — and every plugin that injects shell (dsh's tool-pwsh, permission-presets, …) — is unaffected by this plugin being loaded.
• Why there is no selector any more: dsh 0.1.7 dropped ShellExecRequest.shell, the routing field the pre-0.1.7 shell-select design dispatched on. With no routing input left, the tool is what knows which shell it wants — so the selector has nothing to select on, and is gone.
• Executable resolution and sandbox probing are lazy: a host without Git Bash or WSL does not affect pwsh; failures are loud at first use.
• Git Bash is found automatically, in order: an explicit gitBash.bashPath, Git install roots inferred from git.exe layout directories on PATH (so an install reachable through git is found without a pin, even outside the well-known locations), the well-known Program Files layout on every fixed drive (C:\Program Files\Git, D:\Program Files\Git, ...), bash.exe on PATH, and finally the HKLM\SOFTWARE\GitForWindows install path (which the Git for Windows installer always records, covering portable installs). The Windows WSL launcher System32\bash.exe and WindowsApps app-execution alias directories are never selected, and candidates must be real regular files — symlinks/reparse points are rejected — so a stale WSL bash.exe alias can never shadow a real Git Bash (this tool is MSYS, not WSL).
• Sandbox auto: Git Bash probes the windows-acl runner, WSL probes bwrap inside the distro; a failed probe degrades honestly to an unconfined run with no sandbox facts. An explicit sandbox: bwrap with bubblewrap missing fails loudly at the first wsl_bash command (never at boot), leaving the other backends untouched.
• All rows register host-plane: every session sees the tools regardless of its agent preset.

Sandbox behavior (important — read first ⚠️)

The three backends do not share the same file-sandbox capability:

Backend	Mechanism	enforcement	On probe failure
pwsh	windows-acl restricted-token runner	partial	no probe — always confined (dsh's own executor)
wsl_bash	bwrap (bubblewrap) inside the distro	full	runs unconfined, no sandbox facts
git_bash	windows-acl runner wrapping MSYS bash	partial (when the probe passes)	runs unconfined, no sandbox facts when the probe fails

⚠️ git_bash usually cannot be sandboxed in Git for Windows deployments. The windows-acl runner fails to launch the MSYS bash.exe under a restricted token (CreateProcessAsUserW returns Win32 error 2; cmd.exe and pwsh.exe launch fine). With sandbox: auto, a failed probe degrades to an unconfined run by contract. Do not assume git_bash is protected by the DSH sandbox — for sensitive operations use pwsh (restricted token active) or wsl_bash (bwrap active), or take the explicit escalation-approval path.

⚠️ wsl_bash sandboxing depends on bubblewrap inside the distro. Without bwrap, auto degrades to unconfined as well; the probe verdict is cached for the host process lifetime — after installing bwrap you must restart dsh web (or reload the tool row by editing the profile patch) before it is re-probed.

⚠️ A denial is only classified when the command exits non-zero. If a blocked write is followed by a successful command (echo nope > /etc/x; echo done), the overall exit is 0 and no [sandbox: file access denied] marker is emitted — matching the upstream bash-sandbox rule to avoid false positives. What the sandbox value then says is deliberately narrow: a successful confined run reports denied: false; a failed one whose stderr matches this backend's denial dialect reports denied: true; a failed one that matches nothing reports no denied at all plus [sandbox: the command failed without matching this backend's denial dialect; see stderr] — we do not assert a denial nobody observed. An unwrapped run reports only {mode, unconfined: true}, because a run outside a sandbox cannot have been denied by one.

The sandbox constrains file effects only (workspace-write / read-only); network and other resources are not limited. requireSandbox: refuse unconfined runs when the probe fails (optional hardening). Both backends support requireSandbox: true (default false, keeping the existing degrade-and-run behavior). When enabled, a failed probe (windows-acl unusable for git-bash / bwrap missing for wsl-bash) means: danger-full-access runs as usual (an unconfined run is equivalent to an explicit full-access grant), while read-only / workspace-write calls are refused with an error naming the fix and the escalation path. The tool layer also advertises the sandbox and opens the sandbox_permissions argument, so the model can take the approval-based escalation. Example:

# the win-mb-plugin (core row) / win-mb-tool-git / win-mb-tool-wsl rows in cordis.patch.yml:
# each tool row carries only its own backend's partition
- id: win-mb-tool-git
  name: 'dsh-win-multi-bash/tool-git-bash'
  config:
    gitBash: { requireSandbox: true }

- id: win-mb-tool-wsl
  name: 'dsh-win-multi-bash/tool-wsl-bash'
  config:
    wslBash: { requireSandbox: true }

requireSandbox and sandbox: none are mutually exclusive in intent — explicit none is a deliberate opt-out and stays allowed; requireSandbox only governs the "sandbox wanted but probe failed" case.

Enabling the bwrap sandbox for wsl_bash

wsl_bash sandboxing requires bubblewrap inside the distro. On Ubuntu/Debian:

wsl.exe -d Ubuntu-24.04 -e sudo apt-get install -y bubblewrap   # install straight from Windows
wsl.exe -d Ubuntu-24.04 -e bash -c "command -v bwrap && bwrap --version"   # verify

• The probe targets the first distro from wsl -l -q; if your target distro is not the first, pin it via wslBash.wslDistro in cordis.patch.yml and install bwrap inside that distro (e.g. Ubuntu-24.04; docker-desktop has no bash and cannot be used).
• sudo may require a password (depending on the distro's sudoers configuration); use apt-get install -y for scripting.
• Other distro families: Fedora dnf install bubblewrap, Alpine apk add bubblewrap.
• After installing you must restart dsh web (or reload the tool row by editing the profile patch) — the probe verdict is cached for the host process lifetime, and wsl_bash stays unconfined until then.

Tool prompts (model-facing descriptions)

Each tool description is deliberately small: it states only what its own dialect owns — the shell and invocation, the dialect's path and environment-variable syntax, and (for git_bash) the MSYS note. Everything the family shares is stated once, by the single tool:win-mb-bash prompt section owned by the plugin's core row (the package row, win-mb-plugin): a fresh shell per call plus the workdir rule, [exit code: N] markers with the && / set -o pipefail gating rule, $DSH_* environment facts, sandbox behavior, output truncation, delete/move target verification, the unset-variable ${VAR:?} guard, background jobs, and the escalation contract. The longer dialect notes (MSYS path rewriting, WSL base64 payloads) live in this README rather than in the model-facing text.

Both tools run bash -c, so that safety guidance is worded as in tool-bash, not as in tool-pwsh: $HOME is an ordinary assignable variable in bash, so pwsh's "do not assign to automatic variables" sentence would be wrong here — the bash guard for a computed path is the ${VAR:?} form above, which makes an unset variable fail instead of silently expanding to an empty string.

git_bash's description additionally carries a path-format hint:

MSYS paths work inside Git Bash only — dsh's file tools (read, write, edit) on Windows take native C:\... paths.

So when a command prints an MSYS path (e.g. /d/WorkSpace/foo), convert it to its Windows form (D:\WorkSpace\foo) before handing it to dsh's file tools; inside the bash command itself, MSYS paths are what the shell expects.

workdir accepts native, MSYS and WSL-automount forms. A model told that the dialect's paths are MSYS- or WSL-shaped will naturally write workdir that way, so the resolver translates a single-letter drive form (/c/...) and the WSL automount form (/mnt/c/...) into the native C:\... before the executor hands the value to spawn; MSYS POSIX roots (/etc, /usr, /tmp) and distro-side paths such as /mnt/data are left untouched, and a relative workdir still resolves against the session workspace. Before that translation an MSYS-form workdir failed as spawn <shell> ENOENT — a missing-shell symptom for what is really an unusable cwd.

One section for the family, not one per tool. The tool:win-mb-bash section — owned by the package row (the plugin's core row), and by neither tool — carries that shared guidance: check the [exit code: N] marker on every result and chain dependent steps with && or set -o pipefail, because ; never stops on failure and cmd | tail returns the status of tail, not of cmd. That is guidance about composing a multi-step command rather than about one call's arguments, so it belongs to the prompt instead of the per-call schema; the runtime's own tail truncation is also why a call never needs to bound output with a pipe. Prompt sections live in one global layer keyed by name, so two rows registering the same name throw while two names carrying the same text is duplication — on 0.3.1 the two descriptions were 1299 and 2164 characters with 1117 of them byte-identical, and the exit-status paragraph was assembled twice. The section's text is therefore resolved at every assembly from the tools actually mounted (ctx.tools.get), so git_bash and wsl_bash stay independently switchable: either alone, both, or neither each render exactly one correct copy, and a composition with neither renders no shell guidance at all. Its order is the midpoint of dsh's TOOL_BASH / TOOL_PWSH section orders, read from ctx.systemPrompt.getSectionOrder. The escalation contract and the background sentence are included only while a mounted tool actually advertises sandbox_permissions / run_in_background. The section never reads facts out of another row's description, so it stays self-sufficient whether or not dsh's tool-pwsh is in the composition; the sentences pwsh's own description shares with it are the residue a third-party row cannot edit away.

Row switches: what each combination does. The bundle ships three rows — the core row plus one per tool — and the Plugins page can switch each one, so the combination space is worth stating. Only one combination changes the text; none of them loses information:

win-mb-plugin (core row)	win-mb-tool-git / win-mb-tool-wsl	Result
on	any subset	Intended: each tool states its dialect facts, the core row's section states the shared guidance once, following the mounted subset (a tool that advertises no sandbox_permissions also gets no escalation paragraph).
on	both off	No family tool is mounted, so the section resolves to empty text and the rendered prompt contains no shell guidance and no shell section at all. The two Configure pages disappear with their rows.
off	any subset	The Web client has no package row to find dsh.client on, so it serves no browser half and the Plugins page shows no Configure control. The tools keep working: with the section gone, each tool description carries the shared guidance itself (the fallback, which also logs a warning).

The core row cannot be marked read-only: dsh's plugin manager locks only the rows from its own protected-module list, its own row, and rows its profile patch cannot address (readOnlyReason: "management-required" | "unaddressable") — there is no manifest flag a third-party bundle can set. The composition is therefore built so that switching the core row off cannot half-break anything: the tool rows are the ones a user actually toggles, and the third row above is the only consequence. Two rows became three: 0.3.0 and 0.3.1 shipped only win-mb-tool-git and win-mb-tool-wsl, so a hand-wired profile that is not migrated still resolves and loads both tools and behaves the same; the missing core row only means the shared guidance falls back into each tool description (above) and that the Plugins-page Configure control is absent — which 0.3.1 did not have either. Re-run dsh plugin --profile web add dsh-win-multi-bash, or add the win-mb-plugin row to the profile's cordis.patch.yml by hand, to get the core row. The separate win-mb-shell-prompt row that existed briefly in the development commits between 0.3.1 and 0.4.0 is simply gone — no published version ever declared it, so 0.4.0 ships no module behind that name. A profile that still carries it boots with one inactive entry (the module no longer resolves) and is otherwise unaffected: both tools load, and with no section owner composed each description carries the shared guidance itself.

Two further caveats. A row switched off at runtime takes effect immediately for the section (it is resolved per assembly), but a tool row that was already loaded keeps the description it registered: the fallback therefore appears only after that tool row reloads, or after a restart. And a warning issued at startup goes through cordis's logger, which the boot collector keeps for its failure report but discards on a successful boot at the default log level — so the fallback text, not the log line, is what actually guarantees the model keeps the guidance.

Runtime configuration (the Plugins page)

Both tool rows carry their own configuration, and every knob is declared .volatile() — which is what makes it addressable by the runtime's settings service. The Web Plugins page therefore edits it: open Plugins in the sidebar, open the dsh-win-multi-bash bundle, and each row has a Configure page. The browser half (lib/client.js, declared as dsh.client + the ./client export) registers that page into the page's plugins.row.config slot, keyed dsh-win-multi-bash#<row id>; a save goes to the profile's Cordis patch through settings/ctx.configForms — the same place a hand edit lands, with no HTTP route, no second settings file, and no YAML editing.

That is also why the bundle inserts a third row — win-mb-plugin, name: 'dsh-win-multi-bash' — and why it is the row it is: dsh-client-modules discovers a browser half by resolving a row's bare package specifier to its package.json and reading dsh.client there (locatePkgJson → exactPackageSpecifier, which answers undefined for a subpath). The tool rows are subpaths, so without this core row the client bundle is never served and the rows show no Configure control at all. Its module (lib/index.js) is the package main, and it owns the shared prompt section as well — one row for the plugin itself, one row per tool.

Row	Options (in page order)
git_bash	Background jobs (enableRunInBackground); cwd, timeoutMs, maxTimeoutMs, maxOutputBytes, maxSpillBytes, graceMs; bashPath; sandbox stance (auto / none); probeTimeoutMs; requireSandbox
wsl_bash	The same set under wslBash, plus wslPath and wslDistro, and the stance list adds bwrap

That list is exactly the volatile projection of each row's Config schema — the audit pins both sides (volatilePaths of the host configs against the browser half's field table), so a knob added to a backend without .volatile() cannot silently stay YAML-only, and the page cannot offer a field the Host would refuse.

• Live reads. Volatile fields are live references, and the executors read them through .get() at use time. A path, distro, stance, timeout, or hardening change applies to the next command without reloading the row.
• Two knobs need the row's next load, because they shape the tool's schema rather than one call: enableRunInBackground (the advertised run_in_background argument) and the escalation surface (sandbox_permissions, advertised at load from the probe verdict).
• One behaviour switch is deliberately not on the page. promoteOnTimeout (default on) keeps a foreground command that reaches its timeout running as a background job — visible and killable through the job tools — instead of killing it, matching dsh's own bash tool. It is non-volatile because it is a deployment stance rather than a live knob: set it in the row's YAML and it applies on the row's next load. With enableRunInBackground: false, or with no job registry composed, a timeout kills the command exactly as before.
• An unwrapped run says so. When a command is not wrapped by a sandbox, the result carries sandbox.unconfined: true. When the reason is a failed sandbox: auto probe — we degraded on your behalf — every such result carries a short [sandbox: not applied — ran unconfined under <mode> mode; reason and fix stated once per plugin load], and the first one delivered per row load (whichever channel the model reads first: a foreground result, a promoted result, or a real background job's terminal detail) carries the full explanation instead: [sandbox: not applied — the confinement probe found no usable sandbox, so this command ran unconfined under <mode> mode; repair the sandbox or set sandbox: none on this tool row to accept unconfined runs]. An explicit sandbox: none carries the fact without any note, and danger-full-access carries neither: its mode already says what it is.
• The denial dialect is learned per host. After a successful confinement probe, the row makes one deliberately-denied, harmless write outside the workspace root and keeps that refusal text as an extra signature (a union with the backend's own list), so a localized refusal the backend never enumerates is still classified. The probe target must not exist afterwards; if it somehow does, the row deletes it and discards the discovery. Failure to learn is silent and never blocks the row — and on a host whose runner cannot start the shell at all, no confinement (and no discovery) happens. Measured cost on this host: about +321 ms, once per row load, on the WSL/bwrap path.
• On Windows the workspace-write boundary is object-shaped, and on some hosts it is not available at all. Measured on a win32 host (2026-10-14): the ACL backend's grant follows the object, not the path — a file created inside the workspace keeps its grant even when reached through a hard link placed outside it (writing through the outside name lands on the inside file), while an object created outside never gains the grant (both directions measured against icacls), and reads stay unconfined. On that same host the runner could not start MSYS bash at all (0xc0000142, NtCreateDirectoryObject(\BaseNamedObjects\…) : 0xC0000022), so sandbox: auto degraded on every call and git_bash always ran unconfined — which the unconfined fact now reports per call, including in a background job's terminal detail (the base job view has no sandbox field, so the note is the only channel there). Treat sandbox: auto as a guardrail rather than an absolute boundary, and requireSandbox: true as the fail-closed stance: on a host like that one it refuses every command instead of degrading — git_bash stops working there until the runner can start the shell.
• Background advertising is config-driven here, not registry-driven: run_in_background — and the family section's background sentence that follows it — appears whenever enableRunInBackground is on, and a call in a composition with no job registry fails loudly (background jobs unavailable: load @deepseek-ai/dsh-jobs and @deepseek-ai/dsh-tool-jobs). dsh's own tool instead re-registers itself and drops the parameter while no registry is composed. This factory does not re-register: a parameter that silently disappears depending on boot order is worse than one that refuses with a reason, so the choice is deterministic advertising plus a loud call-time failure.
• Staged, not live typing. The page stages drafts and writes only on Save, fenced by the revision it read; a save the Host refuses keeps the drafts. Emptying a path or a distro stages a clear, so the override drops and the built-in probe resolves again.
• The page exists while the Host serves that row's namespace (whileServed), so a row that is switched off shows no Configure control.

Path conversion (MSYS auto-rewriting)

Git Bash rewrites leading-slash POSIX paths into Windows paths (e.g. <Git root>\root) whenever a native Windows program is called — standard MSYS behavior, not a plugin defect. Calling wsl.exe (or any native exe) with POSIX paths from inside git_bash therefore fails:

wsl.exe -e ls /root                       # ✗ ls: cannot access 'D:/Program Files/Git/root'
MSYS_NO_PATHCONV=1 wsl.exe -e ls /root    # ✓ passed verbatim

• To pass arguments verbatim, prefix the call with MSYS_NO_PATHCONV=1 (or MSYS2_ARG_CONV_EXCL="*"); a single argument can be escaped with a // prefix.
• For WSL work prefer the wsl_bash tool: it spawns wsl.exe directly from Node and ships the command as a base64 payload, so quoting and Linux paths reach the distro verbatim — no rewriting involved.
• The plugin's own internal paths (Git Bash probing, the bwrap workspace root, workdirs) are all passed by Node directly and are never subject to MSYS rewriting.

Package contents

The full feature implementation ships in lib/ as plain ESM JS — no build step — and imports only dsh's published base packages:

lib/
├── bash-git/       GitBashExecutor (MSYS)
├── bash-wsl/       WslBashExecutor (WSL, base64 payloads)
├── tool-bash/      tool factory + git_bash / wsl_bash instances,
│                   backend ownership (types/backend.js)
└── vendor/         helper modules for runner-failure classification and bwrap profiles

Because no row of this plugin registers as ctx.shell, the patch inserts only its own two tool rows and disables nothing: the base bundle's shell wiring (pwsh-sandbox on win32, bash-sandbox elsewhere) stays exactly as shipped, and pwsh keeps working whether or not this plugin is loaded.

Prerequisites

• A dsh profile with the published @deepseek-ai base packages (every standard deployment).
• Git Bash and/or WSL on the machine (a missing backend only errors at first use; pwsh is unaffected).

Install and remove

There is one install path: dsh plugin, a pnpm forwarder. It installs the package into the profile, and the bundle layer applies the package's own cordis.patch.yml (declared by dsh.bundle.patch), which inserts the three rows. No script links anything by hand.

# Install (pick one)
dsh plugin --profile web add dsh-win-multi-bash                    # npm published package (recommended)
dsh plugin --profile web add github:@Dinosaur-MC/dsh-win-multi-bash   # GitHub repository source

# Remove
dsh plugin --profile web remove dsh-win-multi-bash

Requires pnpm; the bundle layer is assembled at boot, so restart dsh web for a change to take effect. Works on any profile, including freshly initialized ones.

The manual equivalent is the profile's cordis.patch.yml: the insert: rows this package's own cordis.patch.yml declares (that file is the composition wiring, documented inline) can be written into the profile patch by hand. Do not do both — a hand-written block next to a bundle install makes the loader reject the duplicate entry ids.

Verification

powershell -ExecutionPolicy Bypass -File .\smoke\run.ps1

Boots a real composition over the profile runtime (modifying nothing), verifies git_bash / wsl_bash register and execute real commands — including an explicit bashPath variant — and asserts ctx.shell is still provided by the base bundle's own row (the regression this plugin once caused). Requires node >= 20.

powershell -ExecutionPolicy Bypass -File .\smoke\audit.ps1

Runs the full audit suite instead: pure-unit coverage of the vendor helpers, executor internals and tool config schemas, plus boot-integration matrices for the real cordis.patch.yml and for misconfigurations.

Troubleshooting

Symptom	Fix
New sessions lack git_bash / wsl_bash	Check the three rows are in the profile's cordis.patch.yml and that the profile resolves dsh-win-multi-bash (dsh plugin --profile web list); the bundle layer is assembled at boot, so restart the running dsh web
Boot fails with duplicate loader entry id	The rows are present twice — a hand-written block in the profile patch next to the bundle install; remove one of them
Boot fails with Cannot find package '@deepseek-ai/...'	The profile runtime lacks the base packages (every standard deployment has them); reinstall with dsh plugin --profile web add dsh-win-multi-bash
git_bash reports bash not found (or spawns the WSL WindowsApps\bash.exe alias with spawn ... ENOENT)	Git Bash is outside the probe paths, or a stale WSL app-execution alias shadows resolution: delete %LOCALAPPDATA%\Microsoft\WindowsApps\bash.exe (Settings → Apps → Advanced app settings → App execution aliases), or set gitBash.bashPath manually
wsl_bash errors	Check wsl.exe --status for a default distro; set wslBash.wslDistro to name one
wsl_bash fails with bwrap was not found	sandbox: bwrap is set but bubblewrap is missing inside the distro: install it per “Sandbox behavior → Enabling the bwrap sandbox for wsl_bash” (sudo apt-get install -y bubblewrap) and restart dsh web, or use sandbox: auto / none
wsl_bash sandbox reports a runner failure on bwrap	The bwrap workspace root is the Linux side of a Windows drive path (/mnt/<drive>/...): a UNC workspace root fails loud, and a distro with a custom automount root (wsl.conf automount.root) needs a matching configuration
Calling wsl.exe (or other native exes) with POSIX paths from git_bash reports No such file or directory	MSYS rewrote /root etc. to <Git root>\root: prefix with MSYS_NO_PATHCONV=1 / MSYS2_ARG_CONV_EXCL="*", or use a // prefix; use the wsl_bash tool for WSL work
wsl_bash still runs without a sandbox after installing bubblewrap	The bwrap probe verdict is cached for the host process lifetime: restart dsh web, or reload the tool row by editing the profile patch
Boot warns win-mb-tool-git … waiting for service: shell (or dsh's own tool-pwsh / permission-presets do)	Nothing provides ctx.shell. This plugin no longer provides it either: check the base bundle's pwsh-sandbox row is not disabled by some other patch

Layout

dsh-win-multi-bash/
├── package.json            # dsh.bundle + dsh.client manifest; exports . ./client ./tool-git-bash ./tool-wsl-bash
├── cordis.patch.yml        # the composition wiring (documented inline)
├── .gitattributes          # LF-only for every text file, binaries exempt
├── LICENSE / THIRD_PARTY_NOTICES
├── lib/                    # bundled implementation (plain ESM JS, no build step)
└── smoke/                  # smoke test (not published)