uncontrollable

What is uncontrollable?

The 'uncontrollable' npm package is a utility for creating controlled components that can also be uncontrolled. It allows you to manage the state of a component internally while still providing the ability to control it externally via props.

What are uncontrollable's main functionalities?

Creating Uncontrolled Components

This feature allows you to create components that can manage their own state internally but can also be controlled externally via props. The `uncontrollable` function wraps your component and allows you to specify which props should be treated as controlled.

const { uncontrollable } = require('uncontrollable');

class MyComponent extends React.Component {
  render() {
    return <input value={this.props.value} onChange={this.props.onChange} />;
  }
}

const UncontrolledComponent = uncontrollable(MyComponent, { value: 'onChange' });

// Usage
<UncontrolledComponent defaultValue="initial value" />;

Handling Multiple Controlled Props

This feature allows you to handle multiple controlled props within a single component. You can specify multiple props that should be treated as controlled, and the `uncontrollable` function will manage them accordingly.

const { uncontrollable } = require('uncontrollable');

class MyComponent extends React.Component {
  render() {
    return (
      <div>
        <input value={this.props.value} onChange={this.props.onChange} />
        <input value={this.props.otherValue} onChange={this.props.onOtherChange} />
      </div>
    );
  }
}

const UncontrolledComponent = uncontrollable(MyComponent, { value: 'onChange', otherValue: 'onOtherChange' });

// Usage
<UncontrolledComponent defaultValue="initial value" defaultOtherValue="initial other value" />;

Other packages similar to uncontrollable

react-controlled

The 'react-controlled' package provides similar functionality by allowing you to create components that can be both controlled and uncontrolled. It offers a more modern API and better integration with hooks compared to 'uncontrollable'.

recompose

The 'recompose' package offers a variety of higher-order components and utilities for managing state and props in React components. While it is more feature-rich and versatile, it can be more complex to use compared to 'uncontrollable'.

README

uncontrollable

Wrap a controlled react component, to allow specific prop/handler pairs to be omitted by Component consumers. Uncontrollable allows you to write React components, with minimal state, and then wrap them in a component that will manage state for prop/handlers if they are excluded.

Install

npm i -S uncontrollable

Usage

If you are a bit unsure on the why of this module read the next section first. If you just want to see some real-world examples, check out React Widgets which makes heavy use of this strategy.

import { uncontrollable } from 'uncontrollable';

API

useUncontrolledProp(value, defaultValue, onChange) => [value, onChange]

A React hook that can be used in place of the above Higher order Component. It returns a complete set of props which are safe to spread through to a child element.

import { useUncontrolledProp } from 'uncontrollable';

const UncontrolledCombobox = ({ value, defaultValue, onChange }) => {
  // filters out defaultValue, defaultOpen and returns controlled
  // versions of onChange, and onToggle.
  const [controlledValue, onControlledChange] = useUncontrolledProp(
    value,
    defaultValue,
    onChange
  );

  return <Checkbox {...controlledProps} />;
};

useUncontrolled(props, propsHandlerHash) => controlledProps

A React hook that can be used in place of the above Higher order Component. It returns a complete set of props which are safe to spread through to a child element.

import { useUncontrolled } from 'uncontrollable';

const UncontrolledCombobox = (props) => {
  // filters out defaultValue, defaultOpen and returns controlled
  // versions of onChange, and onToggle.
  const controlledProps = useUncontrolled(props, {
    value: 'onChange',
    open: 'onToggle',
  });

  return <Checkbox {...controlledProps} />;
};

Use Case

One of the strengths of React is its extensibility model, enabled by a common practice of pushing component state as high up the tree as possible. While great for enabling extremely flexible and easy to reason about components, this can produce a lot of boilerplate to wire components up with every use. For simple components (like an input) this is usually a matter of tying the input value prop to a parent state property via its onChange handler. Here is an extremely common pattern:

  render() {
    return (
      <input type='text'
        value={this.state.value}
        onChange={ e => this.setState({ value: e.target.value })}
      />
    )
  }

This pattern moves the responsibility of managing the value from the input to its parent and mimics "two-way" databinding. Sometimes, however, there is no need for the parent to manage the input's state directly. In that case, all we want to do is set the initial value of the input and let the input manage it from then on. React deals with this through "uncontrolled" inputs, where if you don't indicate that you want to control the state of the input externally via a value prop it will just do the book-keeping for you.

This is a great pattern which we can make use of in our own Components. It is often best to build each component to be as stateless as possible, assuming that the parent will want to control everything that makes sense. Take a simple Dropdown component as an example

class SimpleDropdown extends React.Component {
  static propTypes = {
    value: React.PropTypes.string,
    onChange: React.PropTypes.func,
    open: React.PropTypes.bool,
    onToggle: React.PropTypes.func,
  };

  render() {
    return (
      <div>
        <input
          value={this.props.value}
          onChange={(e) => this.props.onChange(e.target.value)}
        />
        <button onClick={(e) => this.props.onToggle(!this.props.open)}>
          open
        </button>
        {this.props.open && (
          <ul className="open">
            <li>option 1</li>
            <li>option 2</li>
          </ul>
        )}
      </div>
    );
  }
}

Notice how we don't track any state in our simple dropdown? This is great because a consumer of our module will have the all the flexibility to decide what the behavior of the dropdown should be. Also notice our public API (propTypes), it consists of common pattern: a property we want set (value, open), and a set of handlers that indicate when we want them set (onChange, onToggle). It is up to the parent component to change the value and open props in response to the handlers.

While this pattern offers an excellent amount of flexibility to consumers, it also requires them to write a bunch of boilerplate code that probably won't change much from use to use. In all likelihood they will always want to set open in response to onToggle, and only in rare cases will want to override that behavior. This is where the controlled/uncontrolled pattern comes in.

We want to just handle the open/onToggle case ourselves if the consumer doesn't provide a open prop (indicating that they want to control it). Rather than complicating our dropdown component with all that logic, obscuring the business logic of our dropdown, we can add it later, by taking our dropdown and wrapping it inside another component that handles that for us.

uncontrollable allows you separate out the logic necessary to create controlled/uncontrolled inputs letting you focus on creating a completely controlled input and wrapping it later. This tends to be a lot simpler to reason about as well.

  import { uncontrollable } from 'uncontrollable';

  const UncontrollableDropdown = uncontrollable(SimpleDropdown, {
    value: 'onChange',
    open: 'onToggle'
  })

  <UncontrollableDropdown
    value={this.state.val} // we can still control these props if we want
    onChange={val => this.setState({ val })}
    defaultOpen={true} /> // or just let the UncontrollableDropdown handle it
                          // and we just set an initial value (or leave it out completely)!

Now we don't need to worry about the open onToggle! The returned component will track open for us by assuming that it should just set open to whatever onToggle returns. If we do want to worry about it we can just provide open and onToggle props and the uncontrolled input will just pass them through.

The above is a contrived example but it allows you to wrap even more complex Components, giving you a lot of flexibility in the API you can offer a consumer of your Component. For every pair of prop/handlers you also get a defaultProp of the form "default[PropName]" so value -> defaultValue, and open -> defaultOpen, etc. React Widgets makes heavy use of this strategy, you can see it in action here: https://github.com/jquense/react-widgets/blob/5d1b530cb094cdc72f577fe01abe4a02dd265400/src/Multiselect.jsx#L521